A Pilot's Guide to Ground Icing

Module V - Anti-Icing Operations

How to keep it off

Section: Holdover Time Factors

Start This Section

In order to realize the full potential effectiveness of the anti-icing fluid, many factors must be taken into account. For example, the fluid must be handled and applied properly; personnel should verify proper application, the pilot must be trained in the nuances of the HOT tables, and immediately prior to departure, verify that the wings and other critical surfaces are still clean.

Many professional operators have created an entire infrastructure to support this procedure and offload the pilot. In North America, many of these operators have approved de/anti-icing programs; in the UK: those with an Air Operators Certificate follow the procedures in their Operations Manual. In these operations, flight and ground crews receive initial and recurrent training.


Further Information

Operators with approved de/anti-icing programs train both air and ground crews in factors including:

  • Proper storage and handling (heating, dilution)
  • Proper application (uniform thickness, no spray zones, nozzle settings)
  • Proper HOT usage (communicate fluid type and strength, identify precipitation type & intensity, communicate start time, factors reducing HOT)
  • Post fluid application check (who, how)
  • Pre-takeoff check and pre-takeoff contamination check (who, how)
Canadian flag

Transport Canada Statement Concerning Holdover Time Guidelines

In Canada, during active winter weather conditions, for an aircraft certified for flight in icing conditions, you must comply with CAR's 602.11/622.11 and have your critical surfaces free of frozen contamination prior to takeoff. Some private and commercial operators and all airline operators have Approved Ground Icing Programs (AGIP). These programs contain elements such as: the Operator's Management Plan; aircraft de-icing/anti-icing procedures; holdover timetables; aircraft inspection and reporting procedures; and training and testing.

Without an Approved Ground Icing Program, which means training on the use of Holdover Times (HOT) has not been conducted, the pilot would be unable to determine when potential fluid failure would occur and thus would not be able to gain maximum benefit from the HOT. In these cases, an external, tactile, pre-takeoff contamination inspection must be conducted immediately prior to takeoff, which is 5 minutes prior to the takeoff roll.

The use of holdover timetables (HOT) is not mandatory and may be used either as guidelines or decision-making criteria in assessing whether it is safe to take off. When holdover timetables are used as decision-making criteria, only high confidence level times shall be used and the procedures to be followed after holdover time has expired must be clearly documented in the operators plan.

Business Aircraft Operators can get additional information from the Canadian Business Aircraft Association (CBAA) regarding icing programs for their aircraft.

Be sure to check for the current version.

United States flag

Federal Aviation Administration Statement Concerning Holdover Time Guidelines

In the United States, only operators with a FAA approved program as described in FAR 121.629(c) are allowed to use holdover times in any manner other than advisory. This applies to Part 121, 125, and 135 operators.

For aircraft operating under Part 91, which includes private aircraft, there is no regulatory sanction for the use of holdover times.

Operators flying under FAR 121 must have an FAA approved winter operations program to operate in ground icing conditions. The program must include the use of holdover tables, training for pilots and ground crews, and a management plan detailing responsibilities for implementing the program. Alternately, Part 121 operators not wishing to develop a program must conduct an external check to ascertain the aircraft surfaces are free of any adhering frozen contamination and must take off within five minutes of conducting the check (FAR 121.629(d)).

FAR 125 and 135 Operators, after prescribed training, can use the holdover times in an advisory capacity, subject to an FAA approved check of adhering frozen contamination for each specific aircraft type to be accomplished within five minutes prior to takeoff. Additional resources are listed below.

  • FAA Regulations
  • FAA Air Transportation Division
  • FAR 91.527, "Operating in Icing Conditions"
  • FAR 135.227, "Icing Conditions: Operating limitations"
  • FAR 121.629 "Operation in icing conditions"
  • AC 120-58, "Pilot Guide Large Aircraft Ground Deicing"
  • AC 135-17, "Pilot Guide Small Aircraft Ground Deicing"
  • FAA Airline Safety
  • AC 135-16, "Ground Deicing and Anti-icing Training and Checking"
  • AC 120-60B, "Ground Deicing and Anti-icing Program"
  • AC 20-117, "Hazards Following Ground Deicing and Ground Operations in Conditions Conducive to Aircraft Icing"
British flag

Civil Aviation Authority Statement Concerning Holdover Time Guidelines

In the United Kingdom, during winter weather conditions, the following guidance applies if your aircraft is certified for flight in icing conditions. You must comply with Article 52 of the Air Navigation Order (Pre-flight action by commander of aircraft), JAR OPS 1.345 (Ice and other contaminants – ground procedures), 1.346 (Ice and other contaminants – flight procedures) and other relevant regulation, including information contained in the Aircraft Flight Manual.

Hold Over Time (HOT) Guidelines are generally used by Air Operator Certificate (AOC) holders as part of company winter operations procedures and as such fall within the remit of CAA regulatory oversight. Significant training is required before HOT guidelines can be used and therefore they should only be used by competent personnel.

Additional Resources:

De-icing with Type I fluid
Anti-icing large aircraft in snowy conditions

Many professional operators invest in flight and ground crew training

HOT guidelines exist for conditions that have been rigorously tested. The times presented are conservative – that is, within the HOT, the fluid should remain effective. However, there are known factors that can cause fluid failure, even within the HOT. You need to monitor for anything that might reduce the effective HOT, such as precipitation or high humidity, high wind velocity, jet blast, or aircraft skin temperature colder than OAT.

HOT guideline tables contain an "Other" column for heavy snow, snow pellets, ice pellets, moderate and heavy freezing rain, and hail. It is known that some of these conditions (heavy snow, moderate and heavy freezing rain) can quickly overwhelm the anti-icing fluid. Do not depart in these conditions.

Freezing rain on aircraft wing
Type II fluid runoff from wing leading edge

Both precipitation type and intensity are key factors in determining holdover times

Important factors that influence HOT include

  • outside air temperature – the colder it is, the faster a fluid will fail.
  • precipitation type and intensity – the higher the moisture content, the faster a fluid will fail.
  • fluid type and strength – the less viscous (thinner) the fluid is, the faster it will fail.

To get a sense of these variables, explore the Type I and Type IV HOT Guideline Tables found later in this section and the "Further Information" link below. Note: these are sample tables, and should not be used for flight planning purposes.


Further Information

Outside Air Temperature

Although the freezing point of anti-icing fluid is lower than that of pure water, it can freeze. As the air temperature drops, anti-icing fluids become less able to absorb and melt the freezing precipitation.

In addition, as the temperature decreases, the fluids become more resistant to shearing off the aircraft during the take-off roll.

It can get so cold that a fluid cannot be used safely on an aircraft either because it cannot afford any protection or because it may substantially interfere with the airflow over the lifting surfaces. A Lowest Operational Use Temperature (LOUT) is specified for every fluid. When the temperature is below the LOUT, that fluid should not be used. (See Module 3: Fluid Basics for more information on LOUT.)

Precipitation Type and Intensity

Anti-icing fluids work by absorbing and melting precipitation. Conversely, precipitation dilutes the anti-icing fluid. The more dilute the anti-icing fluid becomes, the less protection it affords. Ultimately, the anti-icing fluid will fail. The more moisture present, the shorter the holdover time.

Both the type of precipitation and its intensity are key factors in determining HOT.

Fluid Type and Concentration

Type I must always be applied heated and diluted. It is essentially a de-icing fluid that can also be used for anti-icing in a two-step process. As the least viscous (thinnest) of fluids, it has the shortest HOTs.

Types II, III and IV may be applied unheated or heated, full strength or diluted. The thickening agents added to these fluids to increase viscosity, and correspond to longer HOTs. In general, the more dilute the Type II, III or IV fluid, the shorter the holdover time. Check to see if thickened fluids can be used on your aircraft, and if any changes to the takeoff procedure (e.g., delayed rotation speed) are required.

See Module III: Fluid Basics for a more comprehensive discussion.

Type I Holdover Time Table (Sample)
Type IV Holdover Time Table (Sample)

Type I (top) & Type IV (below) Holdover Time Tables (HOT)

Related Information

SWEDEN
NOVEMBER 24, 1988
C-401

Following de-icing, taxy and run-up, the take-off run was started. Acceleration was normal as were all engine indications. Rotation at 95 kts resulted in a stall warning. The flying characteristics were unsatisfactory, forcing the pilot to abort, braking action was inadequate and the aircraft overran, slid down a slope and across a ditch. The gear sheared off. Disembarkation was carried out without problems.

Minor deposits of snow on the top sides of the wings and water from melting snow refreezing on the lower side disturbed the airflow. It prevented the aircraft from getting airborne at normal lift-off speed and caused the pilot to abort the take-off. The aircraft could not be stopped within the remaining runway length because of poor braking action. Contributing factors included the crew not being aware of the actual glycol / water mixture in the Type 1 de-icing fluid.

Field Experience: Improper Fluid Dilution

"After de-icing the aircraft, we found icicles hanging off the wings. The de-icing fluids' temperature was checked and we found it to be suitable. It turned out that the incorrect ratios were used when we mixed the fluid in the tank of the truck. That particular aircraft was de-iced a second time after we corrected the fluid imbalance."

David McNab
Supt. Aircraft Maintenance & Mfg.
Transport Canada, Calgary Office

Icicles hanging from aircraft wing trailing edge

You cannot protect yourself against all precipitation types and intensities. Some can quickly lead to fluid failure.

Caution

Do not attempt a takeoff in:

  • moderate and heavy freezing rain
  • heavy snowfall
  • ice pellets

Delay until conditions improve.

Also, holdover times have not been evaluated for snow pellets. The level of this hazard is unknown.

Failed Type IV fluid on wing

Failed Type IV fluid on wing

Caution

Although light freezing rain and freezing drizzle have holdover times, the in-flight ice protection systems may not be able to protect your aircraft in these large droplet conditions.

After the anti-icing fluid shears off the wing during takeoff, you may encounter icing conditions which exceed the capabilities of your aircraft ice protection systems.

Freezing rain or freezing drizzle may form a ridge of ice aft of your ice protection system

SAE Type I Holdover Time Guideline chart sample
Please review the cautions and footnotes below the chart for further clarifications

SAE Type I Holdover Time Guidelines (SAMPLE)1
Outside Air Temperature2 Approximate Holdover Times Under Various Weather Conditions
(hours:minutes)
Degress Celsius Degress Farenheit Active Frost Freezing Fog Snow or snow grains3 Freezing Drizzle4 Light Freezing Rain Rain or Cold Soaked Wing5 Other6
Very Light Light Moderate
-3 and above 27 and above 0:45 0:11-0:17 0:18-0:22* 0:11-0:18* 0:06-0:11* 0:09-0:13 0:02-0:05 0:02-0:05  
below -3 to -6 below 27 to 21 0:45 0:08-0:13 0:14-0:17 0:08-0:14 0:05-0:08 0:05-0:09 0:02-0:05    
below -6 to -10 below 21 to 14 0:45 0:06-0:10 0:11-0:13 0:06-0:11 0:04-0:06 0:04-0:07 0:02-0:05    
below -10 below 14 0:45 0:05-0:09 0:07-0:08 0:04-0:07 0:02-0:04        

Note: Compiled from FAA, Transport Canada and AEA Holdover Time (HOT) Guidelines for Winter 2006-2007

Cautions

British flag

The time of protection will be shortened in heavy weather conditions. Heavy precipitation rates or high moisture content, high wind velocity or jet blast may reduce holdover time below the lowest time stated in the range. Holdover time may also be reduced when the aircraft skin temperature is lower than the OAT. Therefore, the indicated times should be used only in conjunction with a pre-takeoff check.

De-icing/anti-icing fluids used during ground de-icing/anti-icing are not intended for – and do not provide – protection during flight.

United States flag

The time of protection will be shortened in heavy weather conditions. Heavy precipitation rates or high moisture content, high wind velocity, or jet blast will reduce holdover time below the lowest time stated in the range. Holdover time may be reduced when aircraft skin temperature is lower than OAT.

SAE Type I fluid used during ground deicing/anti-icing is not intended for and does not provide protection during flight.

This table is for departure planning only, and should be used in conjunction with the pre-takeoff check procedures.

Canadian flag

The only acceptable decision criteria time is the shortest time within the applicable holdover time table cell.

The time of protection will be shortened in heavy weather conditions, heavy precipitation rates, or high moisture content.

High wind velocity or jet blast may reduce holdover time.

Holdover time may be reduced when aircraft skin temperature is lower than outside air temperature.

Fluids used during ground deicing/anti-icing do not provide in-flight icing protection

Chart color legend

 

OAT: Find the appropriate row for the local Outside Air Temperature. See the Cautions if the aircraft is cold-soaked; the effective holdover time may be shorter than listed.

 

Precipitation type and intensity: Find the appropriate column. In snow near freezing, consider using the snowfall intensity vs visibility charts. If the conditions fall in the "Other" column, anti-icing fluid will not protect you. See Module II: Cues for definitions of these weather conditions.

 

Times: The time range reflects the rate or intensity of precipitation. The shorter time corresponds to a heavier intensity within that cell.

 

CAUTION: No holdover time guidelines exist

Chart footnotes:

  1. Type I Fluid / Water Mixture is selected so that the freezing point of the mixture is at least 10ºC (18ºF) below outside air temperature.
  2. Canada: Ensure that the lowest operational use temperature (LOUT) is respected.
  3. US and Canada: To use these times, the fluid must be heated to a minimum temperature providing 60ºC (140ºF) at the nozzle and an average rate of at least 1 litre/m2 (2 gal./100 sq. ft.) must be applied to deiced surfaces, OTHERWISE TIMES WILL BE SHORTER.
    UK: CAA collapses Snow/Snow Grains to one column (moderate), and adds the statement: In light "Rain and Snow" conditions, use "Light Freezing Rain" holdover times.
  4. Use light freezing rain holdover times if positive identification of freezing drizzle is not possible.
  5. UK: No holdover time guidelines exist for this condition for 0ºC (32ºF) and below
    US: This column is for use at temperatures above 0°C (32°F) only
  6. Heavy snow, snow pellets, ice pellets, moderate and heavy freezing rain, and hail

* A Pilot's Guide note: consider use of snowfall intensity vs visibility charts for more accurate determination of intensity.


SAE Type IV Holdover Time Guideline chart sample
Please review the cautions and footnotes below the chart for further clarifications

SAE Type IV Holdover Time Guidelines (SAMPLE)1
OAT Manufacturer Specific Type IV Fluid Concentration
Neat-Fluid Water
Vol%Vol%
Approximate Holdover Times Under Various Weather Conditions
(hours:minutes)
(°C) (°F) Active Frost Freezing Fog Snow/Snow Grains2 Freezing Drizzle3 Light Freezing Rain Rain or Cold Soaked Wing4 Other5
-3 and above 27 and above
100/0 12:00 1:15-2:15 0:35-1:15* 0:40-1:10 0:25-0:40 0:10-0:50  
75/25 5:00 1:05-1:45 0:25-0:55 0:35-0:50 0:15-0:30 0:05-0:35  
50/50 3:00 0:05-0:35 0:05-0:15 0:10-0:20 0:05-0:10    
below -3 to -14 below 27 to 7
100/0 12:00 0:20-1:20 0:25-0:40 0:20-0:456 0:10-0:256    
75/25 5:00 0:25-0:50 0:15-0:35 0:15-0:306 0:10-0:206    
below -14 to -25 below 7 to -13 100/0 12:007 0:15-0:407 0:15-0:307        
below -25 below -13 100/0 Type IV fluid may be used below -25ºC (-13ºF) provided the freezing point of the fluid is at least 7º C (13ºF) below the OAT and the aerodynamic acceptance criteria are met. Consider use of Type I when SAE Type IV fluid cannot be used.

Note: Compiled from FAA, Transport Canada and AEA Holdover Time (HOT) Guidelines for Winter 2006-2007

Cautions

British flag

The time of protection will be shortened in heavy weather conditions. Heavy precipitation rates or high moisture content, high wind velocity or jet blast may reduce holdover time below the lowest time stated in the range. Holdover time may also be reduced when the aircraft skin temperature is lower than the OAT. Therefore, the indicated times should be used only in conjunction with a pre-takeoff check.

De-icing/anti-icing fluids used during ground de-icing/anti-icing are not intended for – and do not provide – protection during flight.

United States flag

The time of protection will be shortened in heavy weather conditions. Heavy precipitation rates or high moisture content, high wind velocity, or jet blast will reduce holdover time below the lowest time stated in the range. Holdover time may be reduced when aircraft skin temperature is lower than OAT.

SAE Type IV fluid used during ground deicing/anti-icing is not intended for and does not provide protection during flight.

This table is for departure planning only, and should be used in conjunction with the pre-takeoff check procedures.

Canadian flag

The only acceptable decision criteria time is the shortest time within the applicable holdover time table cell.

The time of protection will be shortened in heavy weather conditions, heavy precipitation rates, or high moisture content.

High wind velocity or jet blast may reduce holdover time.

Holdover time may be reduced when aircraft skin temperature is lower than outside air temperature.

Fluids used during ground deicing/anti-icing do not provide in-flight icing protection

Chart color legend

 

OAT: Find the appropriate row for the local Outside Air Temperature. See the Cautions if the aircraft is cold-soaked; the effective holdover time may be shorter than listed.

 

Concentration: Holdover times vary according to the fluid concentration.

 

Precipitation type and intensity: Find the appropriate column. In snow near freezing, consider using the snowfall intensity vs visibility charts. If the conditions fall in the "Other" column, anti-icing fluid will not protect you. See Module II: Cues for definitions of these weather conditions.

 

Times: The time range reflects the rate or intensity of precipitation. The shorter time corresponds to a heavier intensity within that cell.

 

CAUTION: No holdover time guidelines exist

Chart footnotes:

  1. Canada: Based on the lowest holdover times of the Type IV fluids [tested this season].
  2. UK: In light 'Rain and Snow' conditions, use 'Light Freezing Rain' holdover times
  3. Use light freezing rain holdover times if positive identification of freezing drizzle is not possible.
  4. UK: No holdover time guidelines exist for this condition for 0°C (32°F) and below.
    US: This column is for use at temperatures above 0°C (32°F) only
  5. Heavy snow, snow pellets, ice pellets, moderate and heavy freezing rain, and hail
  6. No holdover timeline guidelines exist for the conditions below -10°C (14°F)
  7. Canada: Ensure that the lowest operational use temperature (LOUT) is respected.

* A Pilot's Guide note: consider use of snowfall intensity vs visibility charts for more accurate determination of intensity.